The chequered cloth: how were state accounts checked in medieval England?
The British finance minister's post is still called "Chancellor of the Exchequer" today. The word Exchequer comes from a chequered cloth resembling a chessboard. We look at how the sheriffs' accounts were checked at that table.
The British finance minister is still called the "Chancellor of the Exchequer" today. The history of the word "Exchequer" goes back to the chessboard. This is no coincidence: in the Middle Ages state accounts were checked precisely on a chequered cloth.
Where does the name "Exchequer" come from?
In 12th-century England the office that checked the revenues due to the royal treasury was called the Exchequer. Information about how this office worked comes from "The Dialogue concerning the Exchequer" (Dialogus de Scaccario), written by Richard FitzNigel in 1179.
According to it, the name came from the rectangular board on which the accounts were calculated. The board was covered with a chequered cloth resembling a chessboard, and counters (pebbles) for calculating were laid out in the columns on the cloth.
The convenience of this method was that everyone around the table could see the counters in the columns with their own eyes: how much was due and how much had been paid.
How did a sheriff render his account?
In every county there was an official, the sheriff, who collected revenue in the king's name. Once a year, around Michaelmas, he came to the Exchequer to render his account.
The process went like this: - The sheriff sat on one side of the table covered with the chequered cloth, and the senior officials of the Exchequer sat opposite. - An official laid out counters in the columns, showing how much the sheriff owed and how much he had paid. - The result was written on parchment rolls, the pipe rolls. In them the royal revenues were recorded by county for each financial year.
The oldest surviving pipe roll dates from 1130. The series continued almost without interruption until the 19th century and today is kept at the British National Archives under reference E 372. In other words, these documents served as the state's "audit trail" for more than seven hundred years.
What has changed from the chequered cloth to today's audit?
| Aspect | Then (the 12th-century Exchequer) | Now |
|---|---|---|
| Who renders the account | The sheriff, collector of the king's revenue | The company's management |
| Who checks | Officials of the Exchequer | An independent auditor |
| Calculating tool | Chequered cloth and counters | Accounting software and electronic documents |
| Result of the check | An entry in the pipe roll | Auditor's report |
| When | Once a year, around Michaelmas | Based on the results of the financial year |
The core idea at the Exchequer table is very familiar today too: both parties look at one table and agree who owes whom how much. In a modern company the closest counterpart is the statement of reconciliation of mutual settlements.
Example (prepared by the author, hypothetical): the "Qo'qon un" company and its customer reconciled their accounts at the end of the year.
| Indicator | In the books of "Qo'qon un" | In the customer's books |
|---|---|---|
| Flour shipped during the year | 120 000 000 soum | 120 000 000 soum |
| Paid | 95 000 000 soum | 95 000 000 soum |
| Outstanding debt | 25 000 000 soum | 25 000 000 soum |
Both columns matched, so the debt was confirmed. In the 12th century this result was shown by counters; today it is shown by a table signed by both parties.
See also
Sources
- The Pipe Roll Society: How were they compiled? · at Michaelmas the sheriffs' accounts were checked with counters on a table covered with a chequered cloth
- The Pipe Roll Society: What is a pipe roll? · pipe roll: the annual account of royal revenues by county; the oldest dates from 1130
- The National Archives: Exchequer, Pipe Office, Pipe Rolls (E 372) · series 1129–1832, held at The National Archives in Kew (London)
- Medieval Writing: The Exchequer · Richard FitzNigel's "Dialogus de Scaccario" (1179); a board covered with a chequered cloth
- The "Qo'qon un" reconciliation example · prepared by the author, hypothetical